Pages

Wednesday, June 13, 2012

Nothing wrong with separate identities created by Madrasa education, says Asghar Ali Engineer, Islam and Pluralism, NewAgeIslam.com

Islam and Pluralism
Nothing wrong with separate identities created by Madrasa education, says Asghar Ali Engineer
MADRASA EDUCATION - MYTH AND REALITY
By Asghar Ali Engineer
(Secular Perspective Feb. 1-15, 2009)

Madrasas have been at the centre of controversy since 9/11 attack on New York towers. It was thought that attacks were planned by Taliban who were students of madrasas run by Muslims of Wahhabi ideology. Though as far as 9/11 attack was concerned, the madrasas in focus were from North West Frontier Province but in India too madrasas came under fire especially from those who were politically motivated and also from a section of media which took a biased view.

Most of the views about madrasas were expressed by those who hardly had any first hand knowledge of madrasa system or what is taught in these madrasas. They just presumed that since these are Islamic institution they must be teaching about jihad and war. Even responsible ministers from NDA Government in those days made such statements. What is needed is well informed and well studied opinion.

I am glad that Ms. Saral Jhingran has made such an attempt to do systematic study of madrasas system in historical perspective. The other person who has made such an attempt is Yogi Sikand. These studies are most welcome to fight uninformed prejudices even among scholars. These madrasas were set up to fulfil a religious need rather than promote enmity with any community.

http://newageislam.com/nothing-wrong-with-separate-identities-created-by-madrasa-education,-says-asghar-ali-engineer---/islam-and-pluralism/d/1166


0 comments: