Pages

Sunday, June 17, 2012

Deoband resolution on ‘Vande Mataram’ pointless, The War within Islam, NewAgeIslam.com

The War within Islam
Deoband resolution on ‘Vande Mataram’ pointless
Fatwa for nobody
By Aijaz Ilmi
Nov 10, 2009

The Supreme Court had managed to put a firm lid on the Vande Mataram issue, but, true to form, the religious clergy cannot desist from their desire to keep the communal cauldron boiling. When there is no compulsion, what is the need for any resolution or fatwa? Meanwhile, the reaffirmation of an earlier resolution of the Darul Uloom condemning terror is good news — but at the same time we must name the LeT, Jaish and others and send a strong message.

The home minister should be careful about the bouquets, as the brickbats can be as swift. As citizens of a secular democratic country with a vibrant judiciary, fatwas have little meaning in present-day India. Salman Khursheed’s timely rejoinder about the futility of a fatwa about non-issues and the need for addressing the real, burning issues — education and employability of Indian Muslims, for example — are laudable. I wish resolutions at Deoband had addressed the following questions: Why do Indian Muslims have the highest levels of illiteracy, both male and female, in the country? Why do we have the highest number of school drop-outs? Why do we have the lowest representation in both the public and the private sector? What steps are we taking to stop pernicious recruiters who lure young impressionable minds towards terror ideologies?

http://newageislam.com/deoband-resolution-on-%E2%80%98vande-mataram%E2%80%99-pointless/the-war-within-islam/d/2074


0 comments: